Main Ingredients
2 cups granulated sugar
3/4 cup butter (1 1/2 sticks)
2/3 cup evaporated milk
3.4 ounces instant butterscotch pudding mix (dry)
3 1/2 cups quick oats
Dash of salt to taste
1 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips
1/2 cup toffee chips
Why each ingredient matters
The granulated sugar is what builds the caramel body of these cookies. When it cooks down with butter and evaporated milk, it dissolves completely and then boils into a syrup that thickens as it cools, giving the cookies enough structure to hold a shape once they’re scooped onto the parchment. I like to measure it carefully so the ratio of sugar to milk and butter stays balanced; too little sugar and the cookies won’t set, too much and they can crystallize or turn too firm.
Butter is what makes the base rich and smooth. It melts into the sugar and milk and brings that classic caramel flavor that feels round and luxurious on the tongue. Because there’s so much sweetness in this recipe already, I usually stick with regular salted or unsalted butter rather than anything browned or flavored—there’s no need to complicate it, and the simple butter flavor shines once the oats, pudding, chocolate, and toffee join in.
Evaporated milk is one of the secret weapons here. It’s thicker and more concentrated than regular milk, with some of the water cooked off, so it gives the caramel base body and a subtle, almost cooked‑milk depth that tastes like old‑fashioned candy. That extra richness is part of the reason these cookies feel like a cross between fudge, caramel, and a no‑bake oatmeal cookie.
The instant butterscotch pudding mix does double duty. First, it adds a huge punch of butterscotch‑caramel flavor without needing actual caramel candies, which keeps the recipe quicker and more forgiving. Second, the starches in the pudding mix thicken the hot syrup as it cools, helping the oats absorb the liquid and set into firm, chewy mounds instead of spreading into puddles.
Quick oats are essential for the texture. They’re finer and softer than old‑fashioned rolled oats, which means they hydrate faster and give the cookies a more cohesive, chewy bite without big, tough flakes. They soak up just enough of the caramel mixture to hold everything together while still letting the cookies feel soft and slightly fudgy in the center.
Salt is small but important. A dash goes into the saucepan with the sugar, butter, and milk to keep the caramel from tasting flat and one‑dimensional, and a little sprinkle of coarse or flaky salt on top of the scooped cookies highlights the sweet‑salty contrast that makes salted caramel so addictive. It also balances the sweetness from the sugar, pudding mix, chocolate, and toffee so the cookies finish clean instead of cloying.
Semi‑sweet chocolate chips bring deep chocolate pockets that stand up to the caramel base instead of disappearing into it. Semi‑sweet is strong enough to cut through the sweetness but still feels like a classic cookie chocolate, and the bits turn soft and melty without fully losing their shape if you fold them in at the right moment. The toffee chips add another layer of caramel flavor and a little bit of crunch, echoing the buttery notes in the base and making every bite more interesting.
How I set up before cooking
Because this recipe moves fast once the syrup is ready, I like to have everything in place ahead of time. First, I line one or two baking sheets with parchment paper or wax paper and set them on the counter, since that’s where the cookies will cool and set. If I’m planning to make slightly smaller cookies, I know I’ll get more than a single tray can hold, so having a second sheet ready avoids a scramble while the mixture is thickening.
Next, I measure the quick oats into a large mixing bowl and add the dry instant butterscotch pudding mix right on top. A quick stir combines them, so the pudding is evenly dispersed and ready to be hydrated by the hot caramel as soon as I pour it over. Having this bowl ready means I don’t waste any time once the syrup comes off the heat, which helps keep the texture smooth and even.
I also like to place the chocolate chips in a small bowl and slide them into the freezer for a few minutes while I cook the caramel. Chilling them briefly helps them resist melting completely when they hit the warm oat mixture later, so I still get visible chocolate pieces instead of everything turning into a uniform chocolate‑caramel mass. The toffee chips can stay at room temperature; they’re small enough that they don’t need any special treatment.
Cooking the caramel base
In a medium to large saucepan, I combine the granulated sugar, butter, evaporated milk, and a good pinch of salt. I set the pan over medium heat and stir as the butter melts into the sugar and milk, watching for the moment when the mixture goes from grainy to smooth and the sugar is fully dissolved. At this stage, I’m not boiling yet—I’m just making sure I don’t have undissolved sugar sitting at the bottom of the pan that could crystallize later.
Once everything is smooth, I keep cooking until the mixture comes up to a full rolling boil. A proper rolling boil means that even when I stir, the boiling doesn’t stop—it’s a constant, assertive bubbling across the surface. When it hits that point, I start my timer and let it boil for about 30 seconds, stirring regularly to prevent scorching on the bottom. This brief boil is crucial: it cooks off some liquid and thickens the syrup so the finished cookies set up instead of staying soft and sticky.
As soon as the 30‑second boil is done, I pull the pan off the heat. I like to pause here just long enough to give the syrup a quick stir and make sure nothing is sticking on the bottom or sides of the pan, and to confirm that it looks glossy and cohesive. At this moment, it will still be very hot and fluid, almost like a pourable caramel sauce.
Turning caramel into cookie dough
With the syrup still hot but off the heat, I immediately pour it over the bowl of quick oats and dry pudding mix. Using a sturdy spatula or wooden spoon, I stir from the bottom up, folding the oats into the caramel until every piece is coated and there are no pockets of dry pudding left. The mixture will look quite loose at first, but as the pudding starches hydrate and the oats soak up the liquid, it thickens into a glossy, oatmeal‑like mixture that holds together in soft mounds.
At this point, the mixture is still too warm to add the chocolate chips without melting them completely. I let it sit on the counter for a couple of minutes, stirring once or twice to help it cool evenly. I’m looking for a texture that is still warm and pliable but no longer steaming hot—if I touch a bit with the back of my finger, it should feel hot but not scalding.
When it feels right, I pull the chilled chocolate chips from the freezer, add them to the bowl along with the toffee chips, and gently fold everything through. I try to work quickly and avoid over‑stirring, because too much stirring will melt the chips and turn the mixture muddy. If a few chips streak a little, that’s fine; it creates pretty swirls in the finished cookies, but I still want to see distinct bits of chocolate and toffee in every scoop.
Scooping and setting the cookies
With the mixture fully combined, I move straight to the lined baking sheets. Using a medium cookie scoop or a couple of spoons, I drop generous spoonfuls of the mixture onto the parchment, spacing them slightly but not worrying about spreading—they don’t expand like baked cookies. I usually aim for mounds about 1 1/2 tablespoons each, but you can make them smaller for bite‑size treats or larger if you want more of a candy‑bar feel.
While the cookies are still soft and warm on the tray, I finish them with the salted caramel touch. A light sprinkle of coarse or flaky sea salt over the tops adds texture and makes the caramel notes pop, especially once the cookies cool and the salt crystals remain visible on the surface. I try not to overdo it—just a pinch or two per cookie so they taste balanced rather than aggressively salty.
Then I let the cookies sit undisturbed at room temperature for at least 15 to 30 minutes, or longer if my kitchen is warm. As they cool, the caramel base sets and the oats firm up, turning the mounds into solid, chewy cookies that lift cleanly from the parchment. If I’m in a hurry, I can slide the trays into the fridge to speed up the process, but I still like to give them a few minutes at room temperature first so they don’t sweat when they come out.
Continue to the next page to reveal more tips and tricks